In April and May 2023, AgencyEquity published a two-part series predicting that the average independent insurance agency would grow, mainly through acquisitions, retiring agency owners, and industry consolidation.
Three and a half years later, the evidence is clear: Our prediction was correct. Independent insurance agencies are becoming larger, while the total number of agencies is shrinking.
Another important development: This consolidation is creating opportunities for entrepreneurs looking to start their own independent insurance agencies.
The Numbers Confirm Our Prediction
According to the Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America’s (Big “I”) 2026 Agency Universe Study, there were about 37,000 independent insurance agencies in 2026, down from 39,000 in 2024.
That’s a decline of approximately 5.1% in just two years. Meanwhile, average agency staffing rose from 8.2 employees in 2024 to 9.9 in 2026, a nearly 21% increase.
Our earlier analysis also identified a major shift in agency revenues. In 2022, approximately 61% of agencies generated less than $500,000 annually. By 2024, that percentage had fallen to 51.6%. Even more revealing, agencies generating less than $150,000 declined from approximately 38% to 27.1%. These findings strongly suggest the independent agency marketplace is increasingly made up of larger organizations.
Why Is This Happening?
Our original articles identified several factors driving this transformation, most of which remain relevant today.
Acquisitions and consolidation: Larger organizations continue acquiring smaller agencies. Although M&A activity has slowed, OPTIS Partners reported 695 insurance agency transactions in 2025, showing consolidation remains a key industry force.
Retiring agency owners: Many independent agency principals are approaching retirement without successors. Selling to an established agency or acquisition group often becomes the most practical solution.
Technology and operating efficiencies: Larger agencies can spread technology, staffing, compliance, and administrative expenses across more revenue. Smaller agencies must operate efficiently to remain competitive.
These forces are changing the industry, but they are also creating an interesting opportunity.
Fewer Agencies Mean Opportunities for Startups
Here’s something prospective agency owners should consider. The number of insurance agencies is declining, but the need for insurance isn’t disappearing.
Businesses still need general liability, workers’ compensation, commercial auto, property, and professional liability insurance. Homeowners and consumers still need coverage.
In fact, the Big “I” reported that independent agents placed approximately 62% of U.S. property and casualty insurance premiums in 2025.
There is substantial business available with fewer independent agencies competing for it. While consolidation does not necessarily reduce the competitive strength of larger agencies, it can reduce the number of independently owned alternatives available to insurance buyers.
This creates an opening for new agencies offering personalized service, responsiveness, specialized expertise, and direct relationships with customers. Large agencies may have financial resources and technological advantages, but smaller agencies can often respond more quickly, develop relationships within their communities, and concentrate on underserved markets.
A startup agency doesn’t need thousands of customers to become successful. It needs a manageable number of profitable accounts, consistent sales activity, strong carrier relationships, and excellent customer retention. Smaller agencies can also scale by being a member of an Agency Network.
Technology Makes Starting an Agency More Practical
Another important development is the growing availability of affordable technology. Artificial intelligence, digital marketing, comparative rating systems, and modern agency management platforms can help smaller agencies operate efficiently without building large administrative departments.
New agencies can also join agency networks that provide access to multiple insurance carriers, making it easier to enter markets that previously required substantial premium volume. Entrepreneurs who leverage networks and technology can thrive as new agencies. Smaller agencies are also needed because many larger agencies have minimum size accounts that they will except, leaving smaller agencies with solid prospects for accounts under 50k in premium.
Our Prediction for the Next Three Years
We believe consolidation will continue, although not necessarily at the pace experienced during the industry’s most aggressive acquisition years. The average agency will likely become larger, even if new agencies are added as it will take years for the newer agencies to add up to what the numbers they once were.
But the greatest opportunity may belong to the next generation of independent agency owners. As established agencies merge, retire, or become part of larger organizations, there will be opportunities for entrepreneurs willing to build relationships, specialize, and provide the personal attention customers value.
The industry isn’t running out of insurance customers. It’s undergoing a transformation in who serves them. The coming years are likely to be an excellent time to start an independent insurance agency.
Related AgencyEquity Articles:











